Powerpoint Embedded Within PowerpointContemporaneous Notes Spreadsheet

Powerpoint Documents Embedded Within Other Powerpoint Documents

Recently something I came across was Powerpoint documents being embedded within other seemingly unrelated Powerpoint documents. After initial analysis, it looks like it is only an issue with 2003 versions of Powerpoint (maybe other office documents too?). The tool that first highlighted the embedded document was Nuix. When analysing the document in EnCase, no evidence of the embedded document was found.

The embedded Powerpoint is created when using Microsoft PowerPoint 2003 (need to check other versions) and a user chooses the option "Send to Recipient (For Review)". The embedded document is created at this point. The original, that PowerPoint now thinks is going to be reviewed, is embedded into the file that is being sent. In theory the recipient will then make changes, send it back, and the sender will then review and accept (or not) changes. The comparing can be done because the original is embedded within the now modified document. There are suggestions that Outlook can also turn on this Review feature automatically, so when the user chooses "Send to Recipient" without review, it will still embed the document.

The embedded PowerPoint file cannot be viewed natively (either in Windows Explorer or Microsoft PowerPoint), EnCase or in FTK. Even viewing File Structure in EnCase doesn't show the embedded document.
Nuix and some bespoke tools written (many years ago) seem to be the only (tested) tools that are able to access the embedded file.

When analysing at the hex level, I couldn't find any reference to the embedded document within the parent document.

I found some very good resources on this issue, these are listed below (especially the top one):